CFTC Hits Morgan Stanley with $500K Penalty for Overcharging Clients

The regulator said that issues with the reconciliation process were brought to MSCO's attention in early 2015.

Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC (MSCO) has agreed to pay a $500,000 civil penalty to resolve the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s allegations that it failed to adequately supervise the processing of futures exchange and clearing fees, causing it to overcharge some customers.

Register now to the London Summit 2017, Europe’s largest gathering of top-tier retail brokers and institutional FX investors

Join the iFX EXPO Asia and discover your gateway to the Asian Markets

The US commodity regulator issued an order filing and simultaneously settling charges against MSCO, a New York-based registered futures commission merchant and a provisionally registered swap dealer. Morgan Stanley neither admitted nor denied wrongdoing under the settlement.

Suggested articles

What to Look for in a Liquidity ProviderGo to article >>

The CFTC said MSCO developed a proprietary automated system to identify, process, and reconcile exchange fees, but later it discovered it was inaccurate and faulty. However, it noted that the firm self-identified the problem with the fee reconciliation system in 2015 and changed procedures in order to correct it.

According to the order, MSCO’s automated system, by which it identifies and corrects discrepancies between the invoices it receives from exchange clearinghouses and the amounts it pays to customers, was inaccurate from at least 2009 through April 2016, causing the firm to overcharge some customers.

While the CFTC order finds that during that time, MSCO had accrued more than $2 million in excess fees from several clients, it also confirmed that the vast majority of customers’ accounts have been adjusted and fully refunded, and the firm has otherwise taken responsibility to resolve any remaining discrepancies.

Finally, the regulator said that issues with the reconciliation process were brought to MSCO’s attention in early 2015, prompting an internal review that led to modifying its proprietary fee system. The company has already begun implementing improved reconciliation procedures to directly identify potential overcharges, and MSCO “represents that this functionality should prevent future overcharges.”

Got a news tip? Let Us Know