Following the footsteps of its fellow European financial regulators, the Comision Nacional del Mercado de Valores (CNMV), the financial regulatory body of Spain, has decided to increase costumer protection by issuing a new set of rules regarding risk disclosure, trading costs, leverage and advertising requirements.
The local industry was given one month to comply with the new set of decrees, which will come into effect on April 17th. In order to better understand how online trading brokers are coping with it, Finance Magnates sat down with Enrique Martí, CEO of iBroker, to hear firsthand about the process.
Please tell us about yourself and how you reached your current role.
I have been involved in this industry since 2003, working as a manager for financial companies like Interdin, CMC Markets, Auriga and now as CEO and partner of iBroker Global Markets, Sociedad de Valores. My current role involves general supervision of the business, with special focus on sales, marketing, legal and compliance.
Compared with fellow EU regulators, the Spanish watchdog seems to be adopting a lighter approach. What is your take on this?
I personally believe the recent regulation issued by the CNMV is far from being considered ‘light’. Just the opposite, it will demand a big effort for all the brokers, local and foreign, which currently provide services to the Spanish retail investors. It will require major changes in our internal processes as well as the development of new features on our respective front ends.
It does not seem to me a soft approach, but a balanced move from the CNMV to ensure the appropriate customer protection, without imposing any sort of bans that would go against the personal freedom of everyone to invest in what they consider may be good for them.
What are the main changes that brokers will have to implement?
In brief, CNMV has required brokers that currently provide, among retail investors in Spain, (i) CFDs or forex products with a leverage greater than 10 times or (ii) binary options, to show updated warnings as well as collect, for the first 2 trades done in CFDs, FX or binaries, a mandatory written consent. We have already clarified with the Spanish supervisor that this measure applies to existing accounts, not only to new ones. And warning content has to be customized with details like name of the instrument customers pretend to trade, as well as the estimated cost in case they decide to close their position immediately after entering into the transaction.
I personally believe the recent regulation issued by the CNMV is far from being considered ‘light’
For online trading, the regulator requires these new set of rules to be implemented using warning alerts inside the trading platforms, making them visible to customers immediately before they want to trade and capturing the written consent on their own trading device (web or mobile). We all will need to adapt our trading front ends urgently, to be fully compliant with the Spanish watchdog mandate in a months time.
Filling the Gap Between Brokers, LPs, and ClientsGo to article >>
What do you think about the effectiveness of these new requirements? Will they enhance client protection?
I have mixed opinions about this. On one side the client will certainly be better informed and will have to acknowledge these warnings, but on the other side these warning barriers will be a hurdle when trading; having to type on the keyboard a warning acknowledgement phrase does not help at all on fast markets. Once brokers implement the warnings a narrow supervision from the CNMV will be needed to ensure we all comply with the new regulation so all brokers offer the same quality of service.
Similar rules were already in place in Spain from 2013, regarding the suitability test and the way a non-suitable client should be advised of this condition, on every trade, immediately before they trade and capturing, electronically, written consent. This rule was never adopted by some players here in Spain. Hope this time, and for the good of our industry, things will be completely different.
Is the one month transition period sufficient to implement the new rules?
It will be hard, no doubt about it. At iBroker we have already created a special committee, with the only goal of arriving to the 17th of April with a valid solution for the regulator.
How can multi-national brokers comply with the new demands? Will they have to apply the same protection measures to their non-Spanish traders?
To be honest, I am not able to anticipate how multinational brokers are going to deal with this new regulation in Spain. Ideally, they should implement this solution at a country level, affecting just the Spanish traders, but not ‘imposing’ a specific Spanish measure to all their client base worldwide.
How do you view the current state of the industry in the EU?
I foresee a transformation phase in the industry, locally in Spain, as well as in the EU. Regulation and reporting challenges cannot be addressed from small size companies, neither outsourcing core services that hit the heart of the business. But to be clear, I am not saying the biggest players will survive, but the opposite, only the companies that knew how to smartly manage cost efficiency with cutting edge technology will be leaders in the coming years.
What new fields or opportunities do you see as growth potential in the market?
We are a financial company, but the reality is that technology drives every single step of our journey. We need to provide a cutting edge technology to your clients, but at the same time we have to be prepared to adapt this technology to multiple and different requirements. Flexibility to adapt to customer needs and to the always changing regulatory requirements is for me the key to succeeding on this business.
To be honest, I am not able to anticipate how multinational brokers are going to deal with this new regulation in Spain
Also, I see growth potential in exchange traded products. With all these recent new regulations for OTC products across Europe, I can foresee a push for on-exchange products. Futures and options is a field we have always focused on and that we will keep expanding on our product range. We have recently added LMAX Exchange to our CFDs and FX offering, and we are observing that our clients are liking the experience of trading OTC instruments on a regulated exchange, where price fairness and execution transparency is guaranteed.
What are your goals for the company over the next few years?
We want to consolidate iBroker as the number one in Spain offering listed and OTC derivatives to retail investors. In the middle term, we have plans for expanding the business in other UE countries. We currently do business in the UK and the USA, licensing our trading platforms to top brokers and dealers on these regions. We know our proprietary technology is very much appreciated by semi-professionals traders and advanced profiles.