After India's Supreme Court Crypto Victory, What's Impeding Adoption?

Amid all the recent chaos brought about by the coronavirus, there has been perhaps some light for certain aspects of the cryptocurrency world. Following a landmark supreme court victory for the cryptocurrency industry in India, cryptocurrency exchange Binance decided to inject $50 million into India's cryptocurrency ecosystem.

Specifically, Binance put the $50 million into a 'Blockchain for India' fund that promises to invest roughly $100,000 in crypto industry startups based in India. The fund was co-launched with WazirX, an Indian cryptocurrency exchange that Binance acquired in November of 2019.

#Binance and @WazirXIndia announce $50,000,000 USD ‘Blockchain for India’ Fund to foster the growth of the Indian #startup ecosystem.

“Let's invest in #India” - @cz_binance #BlockchainForIndia 🇮🇳https://t.co/piQc4GWp6h

— Binance (@binance) March 17, 2020

CoinDCX, another Indian cryptocurrency exchange, also announced last week that it would be allocating $1.3 million in funding toward increasing awareness, and thereby, adoption of cryptocurrencies throughout the country as part of 'TryCrypto,' a project that seeks to acquaint 50 million people with cryptocurrency.

Our CEO @smtgpt spoke to @Cointelegraph - "Only 5 million people in India hold crypto.

We believe that by educating consumers, we can boost the number from 5 million to 50 million so that everyone can unlock the benefits of digital assets."#TryCryptohttps://t.co/n7HgzSNeb4 https://t.co/SehK5crOEx

— CoinDCX: Making Crypto Accessible to Indians (@CoinDCX) March 17, 2020

Other crypto companies have also shown increased interest in establishing themselves in India--and not just since the supreme court victory. In early October of last year, Bithumb Global announced that it would be opening a regulated crypto exchange in India; just over a month ago, crypto trading platform OKEx expanded into India via a partnership with CoinDCX.

Additionally, Huobi announced its intention to launch a peer-to-peer crypto trading platform in India all the way back in July of 2018. US-based cryptocurrency exchange Paxful began working in India last year, running campaigns with Indian media platforms and influencers to build an online community.

With an unbanked population of 190 million people and a massive, $60+ billion dollar remittance industry, the country could be on the brink of becoming crypto's biggest market.

However, although the recent legal battle turned out to be favorable toward crypto, some analysts are saying that crypto's legal war isn't over yet.

What happened, exactly? Did the overturning of the ban give a clear pathway toward crypto adoption in India? And if not, what does the industry still need to move forward?

The Indian supreme court decided to allow banks to have working relationships with crypto platforms

The supreme court victory for the cryptocurrency industry in India specifically had to do with the country's policy on interactions between banks and cryptocurrency-related businesses.

Before the conclusion of the court case, banks were not allowed to have working relationships with cryptocurrency businesses in India. This was the result of a sweeping ban placed by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in April of 2018.

At the time that the ban went into effect, India's budding cryptocurrency industry was all but forced to shut down completely. While a handful of Indian cryptocurrency exchanges managed to stay in business by modifying their business models and becoming peer-to-peer cryptocurrency exchanges, many--if not most--cryptocurrency exchanges in the country were either forced to relocate or close down operations entirely.

The peril that the ban suddenly put the Indian cryptocurrency industry into caused a number of platforms to challenge the ban. Almost immediately after the ban went into effect, cryptocurrency exchanges filed petitions with India's Supreme Court in an attempt to overturn it.

Crypto has won in India 🇮🇳

We won! #IndiaWantsCrypto

— Nischal (WazirX) ⚡️ (@NischalShetty) March 4, 2020

However, things got worse before they got better. Over the course of the two years that followed, cryptocurrency exchanges in India continuously shut down, and even more severe pieces of legislation made their way through India's legal system. One bill even proposed that the usage of cryptocurrency should be punished with up to 10 years in prison.

By the time the ban was overturned last month, there were only a handful of cryptocurrency exchanges that were still in operation in India.

And hopes are high--" the uplifting of the ban by Supreme Court is going to open new opportunities for India in terms of investments, economy and a market as a whole," said Sumit Gupta, founder and chief executive of CoinDCX to CoinDesk. "As few of the surviving petitioners of the case, we are thankful to the Supreme Court for hearing our side of the story. We have always seen crypto as a potential to unlock India's dream of becoming a $5 trillion economy."

Short- and long-term effects of the overturning of the ban

And even though so little time has passed since the ban was overturned, there have already been some immediate effects.

#Breaking: The Supreme Court of India has struck off the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) banking ban against #Crypto!

We look forward to supporting our partners @wazirxindia and empowering 3 Billion people with the freedom of money.#IndiaWelcomesCrypto 🇮🇳 pic.twitter.com/iYtQ8FqTCV

— Binance (@binance) March 4, 2020

Indeed, in addition to the capital injections from Binance and CoinDCX into various aspects of the industry, Artur Schaback, chief operating officer and co-founder of cryptocurrency exchange Paxful, told Finance Magnates that these effects range "from exchanges offering banking services within hours after the decision was made, to an increase in bitcoin searches online in India."

Indeed, there was a massive increase in the number of searches of the word "bitcoin" immediately following the lift of the ban; less than six hours after the ban was lifted, CoinDCX announced that users could begin purchasing cryptocurrencies with INR as the exchange, becoming the first platform in India to fully integrate bank account transfers post-ban.

The Economic Times, a local financial news outlet, also reported that "several cryptocurrency platforms that had shifted base to Singapore and elsewhere after the RBI circular that was issued on April 6, 2018, are now looking to move back to India."

RBI is reportedly moving to re-instate the ban

However, Manish Kataria, chief operating officer and co-founder of Quadency, said that true change as a result of the ban's overturning would likely take more time.

"The immediate effects are quite limited," Kataria said. "This blanket ban and associated regulatory uncertainty has been stifling innovation for so long that we're just starting to get insights into how exchanges and other providers are planning to scale not just their Indian market presence, but also adoption itself."

And there's also the fact that just as soon as the ban was overturned, the RBI made swift movements to appeal the decision. Within days after the ruling, the Economic Times reported that the bank was planning on returning to the Supreme Court to fight the decision.

And the bank may have a good deal of support behind it. Despite the fact that some Indian banks have already made moves to work with cryptocurrency firms, some of the country's major banks--including HDFC and Indusind Bank--have chosen to ignore the court's overturning of the ban, saying that they are waiting for the official word from the RBI itself before they begin providing services to crypto companies.

Certain banks have chosen to continue not to serve cryptocurrency firms

The Economic Times reported that in an attempt to address the continuous denial of services, Mohammed Danish of Indian law firm Fintech Lawyers sent a letter to Finance Secretary Ajay Bhushan Pandey and two RBI officers.

Since the case has been ostensibly closed, "the banks (RBI regulated entities) must comply with the order of the supreme court and start providing banking services for sale/purchase of crypto assets impartially as they provide services for all other legitimate transactions," Danish wrote.

However, Danish acknowledged that "it is pertinent to mention that the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court has given no specific direction to RBI for issuing a separate notification to the banks for compliance of the said order." In other words, RBI has not officially instructed banks to re-open services to crypto platforms, even though the court has made its official decision.

Still, Danish argued in his letter that "Banks' refusal to provide services for sale/purchase of crypto assets is absolutely illegal, unjust and arbitrary in the eyes of [the] law and the same amounts to wilful disobedience to the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court."

But some banks are still refusing to act until they hear directly from RBI. "We will be guided by RBI's directions on the matter and once we get clarity we will act appropriately," an unnamed senior banker told the Economic Times.

Banks still have concerns over crypto

This is allegedly because the banks still feel as though their concerns regarding the usage of cryptocurrency have not been addressed: "as banks, some of the concerns we had on cryptocurrencies were around security, use of money and traceability," the banker said.

And indeed, while the overturning of the ban was a big victory for India's cryptocurrency industry, the country still has not passed any more general legislation regarding the regulation of cryptocurrencies.

In fact, some analysts have argued that this lack of legislation--in spite of the overturning of the ban--has left the industry vulnerable. In fact, Business Insider India reported shortly after the ban was overturned that the "Banning of Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill," which is currently making its way through the Indian legislative system, has the potential to hinder the industry.

Indeed, the bill currently proposes the creation of unique regulatory frameworks for virtual currencies, utility tokens, and commodity-backed tokens. However, the bill has been said to likely create a complex and exclusionary legislative apparatus that would be difficult for Indian Blockchain Blockchain Blockchain comprises a digital network of blocks with a comprehensive ledger of transactions made in a cryptocurrency such as Bitcoin or other altcoins.One of the signature features of blockchain is that it is maintained across more than one computer. The ledger can be public or private (permissioned.) In this sense, blockchain is immune to the manipulation of data making it not only open but verifiable. Because a blockchain is stored across a network of computers, it is very difficult to tampe Blockchain comprises a digital network of blocks with a comprehensive ledger of transactions made in a cryptocurrency such as Bitcoin or other altcoins.One of the signature features of blockchain is that it is maintained across more than one computer. The ledger can be public or private (permissioned.) In this sense, blockchain is immune to the manipulation of data making it not only open but verifiable. Because a blockchain is stored across a network of computers, it is very difficult to tampe Read this Term businesses to navigate.

Siddarth Mahajan, a partner at law firm Athena Legal, told the publication that "it remains to be seen if the government will rethink the proposed bill in light of the Supreme Court judgment. This regulatory uncertainty in India is probably the biggest concern for the government."

"[...] It remains to be seen if the cryptocurrency business in India is positioned as a financial instrument or commodity with underlying value," Mahajan explained. "The biggest fear of the RBI is the proliferation of unregulated financial instruments which are not backed by the state."

India's number of cryptocurrency users is still relatively low, but that could quickly change

And if "proliferation" of these as-yet unregulated currencies is a serious concern for Indian banks, it seems that there's still a long way to go before cryptocurrency becomes anything close to ubiquitous.

Indeed, the estimated number of cryptocurrency users in India ranges quite a bit, depending on who you ask. "I've seen experts' estimations of crypto adoption in India ranging from .02% to .06%," Kataria told Finance Magnates.

Similarly, Artur Schaback said that "Some official figures state that India has 1.7 million crypto investors, while others indicate over 5 million."

On the other hand, the industry in the rest of the world does seem to be growing at a rapid pace. Data from German-based statistics company Statista shows that in Q1 of 2016, there were roughly 8.95 million blockchain wallet users worldwide; by Q1 of 2018, that figure had climbed to 25.76 million. By the end of 2019, there were 44.69 million.

Because India's population is so large (1.339 billion as of 2017), Kataria pointed out that "even a fractional percentage increase brings millions of new consumers into crypto."

"Meanwhile, the global industry--from DeFi and lending to Payments Payments One of the bases of mediums of exchange in the modern world, a payment constitutes the transfer of a legal currency or equivalent from one party in exchange for goods or services to another entity. The payments industry has become a fixture of modern commerce, though the players involved and means of exchange have dramatically shifted over time.In particular, a party making a payment is referred to as a payer, with the payee reflecting the individual or entity receiving the payment. Most commonl One of the bases of mediums of exchange in the modern world, a payment constitutes the transfer of a legal currency or equivalent from one party in exchange for goods or services to another entity. The payments industry has become a fixture of modern commerce, though the players involved and means of exchange have dramatically shifted over time.In particular, a party making a payment is referred to as a payer, with the payee reflecting the individual or entity receiving the payment. Most commonl Read this Term and commerce--has continued maturing, so we could see adoption accelerate at an even faster pace in India than before the ban." This could lead to increased anxiety from already-skeptical banks in the country.

Is India waiting to regulate until the industry is better understood?

Alternatively, however, the fact that a concrete set of regulations for crypto in India doesn't exist yet could also mean that the government is willing to observe the growth of the industry for a while before making any hard and fast decisions about how appropriate regulation might look in India.

Indeed, Srinivas Katta, partner at IndusLaw, told Business Insider that policymakers should consider how cryptocurrencies could be used to build India's economy before acting.

"Cryptocurrency and tokens are an important development and can enable further formalization of the economy if properly implemented," he said. "They can also promote new industries and bring in a lot of investment [as well as] promote the ease of doing business, which is very important."

And even if there isn't a concrete set of regulations for India's crypto industry just yet, the government is still taking steps toward improving the hygiene of the space. On Monday, a filing submitted to the country's lower parliament revealed investigations into two bitcoin companies, Zeb IT Services, and Unocoin Technologies, for a number of allegedly fraudulent practices.

What do you think about the current legal situation surrounding cryptocurrency in India? Let us know in the comments below.