HSBC Said to Take Loss on Irish Oil Minnow Loans as Pain Spreads

HSBC Holdings Plc is discovering the oil crash extends far beyond the deserts of the Gulf, the plains of...

HSBC Holdings Plc is discovering the oil crash extends far beyond the deserts of the Gulf, the plains of west Texas and the shale fields of North Dakota. Even a small energy company in Dublin can inflict pain.

The lender led a group of banks that extended up to $500 million three years ago to Petroceltic International Plc, helping the Irish oil and gas explorer develop its prized gas field in the southeast of Algeria. With the company now facing a collapse in energy prices and locked in a feud with an ex-Deutsche Bank AG trader-turned-activist shareholder, HSBC has sold its loans at about 30 percent of face value, according to people with knowledge of the sale.

HSBC’s soured relationship with a client it once touted on the bank’s website illustrates the boom-to-bust in energy lending driven by falling oil prices. While Europe’s lenders say many of their loans are to industry giants that can ride out the slump, that still leaves $113 billion in lending to minnows, wildcatters and other junk-rated companies, Bank of America Corp. analysts wrote last month.

“A lot of these smaller, independent companies are really stressed under the current oil price,’’ said Victoria McCulloch, an energy analyst in Edinburgh with Royal Bank of Canada. “This year is going to be tough for the banks that lent to them.”

Petroceltic applied for protection from its creditors in Dublin this month through an Irish form of Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Worldview Capital Management LLP, an activist shareholder that’s been fighting for control since 2014, purchased the majority of its $233 million of outstanding debts the next day from HSBC and the International Finance Corp., a branch of the World Bank, the people said.

Selling Out

Worldview, controlled by a Bulgarian ex-Deutsche Bank proprietary trader named Angelo Moskov, paid about 30 cents on the dollar for the loans, inflicting losses of about $112 million on lead lender HSBC and IFC, according to the people. Sarah Marquer, a spokeswoman for HSBC, declined to comment on the sale of loans. Petroceltic’s application to seek creditor protection made prospects of repaying loans “even more uncertain” and selling out to Worldview was in the IFC’s best interests, Frederick Jones, a spokesman in Washington, said in an e-mail.

Much has changed since April 2013 when Petroceltic tapped HSBC, IFC, Standard Chartered Plc and Nedbank Group Ltd. for a debt facility to boost production in Egypt and Bulgaria and fund development of the Ain Tsila gas field in the Algerian desert. Natural gas prices were double their current level and oil was trading around $90 per barrel.

IFC described the deal as part of its strategy to “support companies in emerging markets with strong management teams.” HSBC placed a video on its website of Petroceltic Chief Executive Officer Brian O’Cathain and Chief Financial Officer Tom Hickey discussing their relationship with the bank.

Oil Exposure

Today, the HSBC video no longer plays. Petroceltic’s shares were suspended March 7 at about 7 pence each, down 96 percent from two years earlier.

The unraveling of Petroceltic, which employs about 160 people from Dublin to Africa, shows how much European banks have to lose among the smaller oil and gas companies that focus just on exploration and production, known as E&Ps. Almost 35 percent of E&Ps, some 175 publicly-traded companies worldwide, are “high risk” with more than $150 billion of debt and weak ability to service it, according to a Deloitte LLP report.

About $5 billion of HSBC’s $29 billion oil and gas exposure is to “pure producers.” The bank took $300 million of charges against its energy loans last year, and added another $200 million to its reserves as it saw oil prices remaining low. CEO Stuart Gulliver has placed the sector under “enhanced monitoring” and curtailed the lender’s “risk appetite,” according to the company’s annual report.

Potential Losses

Suggested articles

How the OKEx Saga Reveals the Need for Decentralized ExchangesGo to article >>

Souring energy debts are another drag for lenders that are already struggling to boost profit as the industry faces tougher capital rules and multi billion-dollar fines for misconduct. Deutsche Bank said it had $17.8 billion of oil and gas exposure at the end of 2015, while Societe Generale SA had more than $26 billion.

European banks stressed to investors during the past month that many of their oil and gas loans are to global “integrated” companies such as BP Plc and Exxon Mobil Corp. Still, they have $113 billion in loans outstanding to energy companies with non-investment grade credit ratings, a portfolio that could trigger $27 billion of losses, Bank of America analysts Alastair Ryan and Michael Helsby wrote in a note to clients last month.

More than 50 E&P companies with debts of about $17.4 billion have filed for bankruptcy in the U.S. and Canada since 2015, according to law firm Haynes & Boone LLP, which advises on debt restructurings and asset sales. They include Swift Energy Co., which filed in December with $1.2 billion of debt, and Escalera Resources Co., which sought creditor protection in November owing $37 million to Societe Generale SA, the majority of which isn’t secured against any assets, according to U.S. legal filings.

‘Not Differentiating’

In the wake of the 2008 credit crunch and the European sovereign debt crisis that followed, the continent’s lenders relaxed some lending standards as oil prices soared and they sought loan growth, according to Bridget Gandy, co-head of financial institutions for Europe, the Middle East and Africa at Fitch Ratings in London.

“There was a move back to not differentiating on risk as much as they had been just after the crisis,” said Gandy. “Something happened that no one was expecting, and you suddenly see the risk pop up.”

The risk on Petroceltic almost panned out for shareholders. In October 2014, with oil trading for about $90 per barrel, the company received a 492 million-pound ($700 million) buyout bid from Dragon Oil Plc. Within two months, the price of oil had tumbled by one-quarter, and Dragon pulled out of the deal.

Enter Moskov, who spent 2015 trying to oust top executives and prevent any more fundraising after taking a more than 20 percent stake. Worldview requested a number of emergency general meetings and sued Petroceltic. The company said the suit, which is still pending in Ireland, was “totally without merit.”

On March 3, Worldview offered to buy the company for 3 pence a share, a bid that Petroceltic directors said undervalued the company. In buying out HSBC and IFC’s loans, Moskov has secured much control over Petroceltic’s future. Spokesmen for Worldview and Petroceltic declined to comment.

“Petroceltic’s lending banks will have observed the deterioration of operating and financial performance and, in light of the shareholder conflict, appear to have chosen to cut their losses,” said Mark Henderson, an analyst with Stockdale Securities Ltd. in London. “Worldview is now in control.”

–With assistance from David Scheer To contact the reporters on this story: Donal Griffin in London at, Stephen Morris in London at To contact the editors responsible for this story: Michael J. Moore at, Jon Menon

By: Donal Griffin and Stephen Morris

©2016 Bloomberg News

Got a news tip? Let Us Know