The recent landmark fines imposed by the Australian courts against three CFD providers totaling $75million is a timely reminder to ensure that your firm has an adequately structured insurance program that can respond to these losses.
Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance is mandated by ASIC for those AFSL holders providing services to retail clients. On the recent ASIC Market Liaison Forum, Cathie Armour of ASIC acknowledged that the difficulty of
obtaining PI insurance is an issue they are aware of and are having a look at. ASIC noted that it has not come to any particular conclusions, having for a number of years now reviewed whether this type of insurance is the best way to achieve the goals of the financial system.
A question regarding the potential for use of alternative arrangements, which is outlined in ASIC’s RG126 was met with a qualified response, noting that ASIC considers for the retail OTC derivatives market, it is really important that PI insurance is in place. Likewise, no details were given to attendees about what, for other financial services participants such as stockbrokers, would qualify as acceptable alternative arrangements.
What Else Am I Missing?
However, the distraction of the PI insurance issues means that many CFD brokers overlook other valuable insurances, especially given the escalating costs and difficulties of the PI insurance, which they are required by law to have, leaving themselves exposed.
To make it simple, we have a look at what is covered by other types of insurance policies, which you may not have considered:
• Directors and Officers’
• Statutory Liability
Kohle Capital Strengthening Retail OfferingGo to article >>
Directors and Officers
Whilst Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability insurance affords some protection for fines and penalties, broadly speaking, this cover extends only to fines imposed against the individual directors and others classified as officers under the Corporations Act. D&O policies do not generally extend to fines against the entity, which was the case with AGM and the other entities under their AFSL, which were dealing in CFDs.
Additionally, pre-Hayne Royal Commission a number of Professional Indemnity policies included, albeit sub-limited, extensions for fines and penalties against the Insured. However, post-Hayne we have largely seen this cover removed.
Whilst the fines imposed against the three CFD providers does not reflect the average risk for many firms, it is vitally important for AFSL holders to manage their exposure to regulatory risk – a good way to do this is via a stand-alone Statutory Liability policy.
A Statutory Liability policy can provide cover for the company, senior management and employees for allegations of wrongful breaches of key legislation in the course of providing professional services and may extend to supplementary legal expenses.
We encourage you to review your current insurance program with your insurance broker so that you are comfortable with your inclusions and exclusions.
Ben Glover is the Founder and Managing Director of Insight Risk Advisers.