Should Clients Cover Their Own Negative Balance?
- Our article "Are You Covered? These Brokers Forgive Negative Balance following CHF Crisis" made our guest blogger Ron de Luca raise the question whether traders should be held responsible for the negative balance or not. What is your opinion? Feel free to submit a blog post about this issue. More details can be found at the end of the article.
This article is written by Ron De Luca who is a senior risk analyst at Mercer Capital Ltd., a NZ regulated forex brokerage.
Since the Swiss Franc crisis shook the global currency market, many brokers either became insolvent (Alpari) or are well on their way to becoming insolvent (FXCM). There is now a debate amongst brokers about whether or not traders should be responsible for negative account balances. This article will address why I believe the traders should never be responsible for Negative Balance Negative Balance In its most basic form, a negative balance represents an account balance in which debits exceed credits. A negative balance indicates that the account holder owes money. A negative balance on a loan indicates that the loan has not been repaid in full, while a negative bank balance indicates that the account holder has overspent.In the retail brokerage space, this phenomenon occurs when a position’s losses in an account exceeds the available margin on hand from a given trader. When a trader place In its most basic form, a negative balance represents an account balance in which debits exceed credits. A negative balance indicates that the account holder owes money. A negative balance on a loan indicates that the loan has not been repaid in full, while a negative bank balance indicates that the account holder has overspent.In the retail brokerage space, this phenomenon occurs when a position’s losses in an account exceeds the available margin on hand from a given trader. When a trader place Read this Term reimbursement.
One of the main causes of this issue are the risky margin call level settings that many reputable brokers offer to traders. These levels are typically below what should be considered safe from a proper Risk Management Risk Management One of the most common terms utilized by brokers, risk management refers to the practice of identifying potential risks in advance. Most commonly, this also involves the analysis of risk and the undertaking of precautionary steps to both mitigate and prevent for such risk.Such efforts are essential for brokers and venues in the finance industry, given the potential for fallout in the face of unforeseen events or crises. Given a more tightly regulated environment across nearly every asset class, One of the most common terms utilized by brokers, risk management refers to the practice of identifying potential risks in advance. Most commonly, this also involves the analysis of risk and the undertaking of precautionary steps to both mitigate and prevent for such risk.Such efforts are essential for brokers and venues in the finance industry, given the potential for fallout in the face of unforeseen events or crises. Given a more tightly regulated environment across nearly every asset class, Read this Term perspective. The reason is there are many scam brokers in the market offering too-good-to-be-true trading conditions. The reputable brokers then need to compete by offering unrealistic terms to new clients.
Because the brokers allow traders to use almost all of their equity before being stopped
out, there’s not enough padding at a margin call to properly exit a trade in extreme market movements. Therefore, the investor’s account hits a minus because there’s no one in the market to take the other side of the trade.
The question then arises: Should the client be responsible for the negative balance? The answer is simply "no" for the following reasons.
1. The client chose to invest a specific amount of money. When the investment was made, the investor did not request a loan from the broker in the case of the account going into negative. The investment is the maximum amount of money the trader is willing to lose.
2. Just as investors need to manage their own risk parameters when investing, so do forex brokers. They have full teams devoted to managing company risk. If the margin call settings are too risky, client accounts can dip into the negative.
It’s important to find a reputable broker with realistic trading terms. This allows the trader to have a fair opportunity to profit and the broker can minimize their risk.
This article is part of the Forex Magnates Community project. If you wish to become a guest contributor, please get in touch with our Community Manager and UGC Editor Leah Grantz leahg@forexmagnates.com
This article is written by Ron De Luca who is a senior risk analyst at Mercer Capital Ltd., a NZ regulated forex brokerage.
Since the Swiss Franc crisis shook the global currency market, many brokers either became insolvent (Alpari) or are well on their way to becoming insolvent (FXCM). There is now a debate amongst brokers about whether or not traders should be responsible for negative account balances. This article will address why I believe the traders should never be responsible for Negative Balance Negative Balance In its most basic form, a negative balance represents an account balance in which debits exceed credits. A negative balance indicates that the account holder owes money. A negative balance on a loan indicates that the loan has not been repaid in full, while a negative bank balance indicates that the account holder has overspent.In the retail brokerage space, this phenomenon occurs when a position’s losses in an account exceeds the available margin on hand from a given trader. When a trader place In its most basic form, a negative balance represents an account balance in which debits exceed credits. A negative balance indicates that the account holder owes money. A negative balance on a loan indicates that the loan has not been repaid in full, while a negative bank balance indicates that the account holder has overspent.In the retail brokerage space, this phenomenon occurs when a position’s losses in an account exceeds the available margin on hand from a given trader. When a trader place Read this Term reimbursement.
One of the main causes of this issue are the risky margin call level settings that many reputable brokers offer to traders. These levels are typically below what should be considered safe from a proper Risk Management Risk Management One of the most common terms utilized by brokers, risk management refers to the practice of identifying potential risks in advance. Most commonly, this also involves the analysis of risk and the undertaking of precautionary steps to both mitigate and prevent for such risk.Such efforts are essential for brokers and venues in the finance industry, given the potential for fallout in the face of unforeseen events or crises. Given a more tightly regulated environment across nearly every asset class, One of the most common terms utilized by brokers, risk management refers to the practice of identifying potential risks in advance. Most commonly, this also involves the analysis of risk and the undertaking of precautionary steps to both mitigate and prevent for such risk.Such efforts are essential for brokers and venues in the finance industry, given the potential for fallout in the face of unforeseen events or crises. Given a more tightly regulated environment across nearly every asset class, Read this Term perspective. The reason is there are many scam brokers in the market offering too-good-to-be-true trading conditions. The reputable brokers then need to compete by offering unrealistic terms to new clients.
Because the brokers allow traders to use almost all of their equity before being stopped
out, there’s not enough padding at a margin call to properly exit a trade in extreme market movements. Therefore, the investor’s account hits a minus because there’s no one in the market to take the other side of the trade.
The question then arises: Should the client be responsible for the negative balance? The answer is simply "no" for the following reasons.
1. The client chose to invest a specific amount of money. When the investment was made, the investor did not request a loan from the broker in the case of the account going into negative. The investment is the maximum amount of money the trader is willing to lose.
2. Just as investors need to manage their own risk parameters when investing, so do forex brokers. They have full teams devoted to managing company risk. If the margin call settings are too risky, client accounts can dip into the negative.
It’s important to find a reputable broker with realistic trading terms. This allows the trader to have a fair opportunity to profit and the broker can minimize their risk.
This article is part of the Forex Magnates Community project. If you wish to become a guest contributor, please get in touch with our Community Manager and UGC Editor Leah Grantz leahg@forexmagnates.com