Financial and Business News

BNY and State Street see FX decline in Q4 2011

Friday, 20/01/2012 | 07:44 GMT by Adil Siddiqui
  • Two of the worlds leading custodian banks have seen a difficult end to 2011 as results show declines in profit and FX revenue. Surprisingly both banks have been under the regulators radar.
BNY and State Street see FX decline in Q4 2011

Two of the worlds leading custodian banks have seen a difficult end to 2011 as results show declines in profit and FX revenue. Surprisingly both banks have been under the regulators radar.

BNY Mellon announced a significant reduction in profit, the group made $505 million; down by 26%.

Their FX division saw an 11% reduction in revenue compared to 2010.

On the other hand, State Street saw revenue on an operating basis ending flat however the $2.29 billion measured below Wall Street analysts who estimated $2.4 billion.

Their FX revenues were down by 12%.

BNY Mellon has been facing a civil suit against them on the back of one if its pension finds claiming they were overcharged for dealings in Foreign Exchange . State Street saw the SEC investigate the pricing they gave to their custodial clients.

2011 was a strong year for ECN's as Volatility helped trade volumes, however BNY and State Streets decline in trade volumes shows how important reputation is in this fast paced industry.

Two of the worlds leading custodian banks have seen a difficult end to 2011 as results show declines in profit and FX revenue. Surprisingly both banks have been under the regulators radar.

BNY Mellon announced a significant reduction in profit, the group made $505 million; down by 26%.

Their FX division saw an 11% reduction in revenue compared to 2010.

On the other hand, State Street saw revenue on an operating basis ending flat however the $2.29 billion measured below Wall Street analysts who estimated $2.4 billion.

Their FX revenues were down by 12%.

BNY Mellon has been facing a civil suit against them on the back of one if its pension finds claiming they were overcharged for dealings in Foreign Exchange . State Street saw the SEC investigate the pricing they gave to their custodial clients.

2011 was a strong year for ECN's as Volatility helped trade volumes, however BNY and State Streets decline in trade volumes shows how important reputation is in this fast paced industry.

About the Author: Adil Siddiqui
Adil Siddiqui
  • 1625 Articles

More from the Author

Institutional FX

Executive Interview | Charlotte Bullock | Chief Product Officer, Bank of London | FMLS:25

Executive Interview | Charlotte Bullock | Chief Product Officer, Bank of London | FMLS:25

In this interview, we sat down with Charlotte Bullock, Head of Product at The Bank of London, previously at SAP and now shaping product at one of the sector’s most ambitious new banking players. Charlotte reflects on the Summit so far and talks about the culture inside fintech banks today. We look at the pressures that come with scaling, and how firms can hold onto the nimble approach that made them stand out early on. We also cover the state of payments ahead of her appearance on the payments roundtable: the blockages financial firms face, the areas that still need fixing, and what a realistic solution looks like in 2026.

In this interview, we sat down with Charlotte Bullock, Head of Product at The Bank of London, previously at SAP and now shaping product at one of the sector’s most ambitious new banking players. Charlotte reflects on the Summit so far and talks about the culture inside fintech banks today. We look at the pressures that come with scaling, and how firms can hold onto the nimble approach that made them stand out early on. We also cover the state of payments ahead of her appearance on the payments roundtable: the blockages financial firms face, the areas that still need fixing, and what a realistic solution looks like in 2026.
More Videos

  • Executive Interview | Drew Niv | Chief Strategy Officer, ATFX Connect | FMLS:25

    Executive Interview | Drew Niv | Chief Strategy Officer, ATFX Connect | FMLS:25

    In this conversation, we sit down with Drew Niv, CSO at ATFX Connect and one of the most influential figures in modern FX. We speak about market structure, the institutional view on liquidity, and the sharp rise of prop trading, a sector Drew has been commenting on in recent months. Drew explains why he once dismissed prop trading, why his view changed, and what he now thinks the model means for brokers, clients and risk managers. We explore subscription-fee dependency, the high reneging rate, and the long-term challenge: how brokers can build a more stable and honest version of the model. Drew also talks about the traffic advantage standalone prop firms have built and why brokers may still win in the long run if they take the right approach.

    In this conversation, we sit down with Drew Niv, CSO at ATFX Connect and one of the most influential figures in modern FX. We speak about market structure, the institutional view on liquidity, and the sharp rise of prop trading, a sector Drew has been commenting on in recent months. Drew explains why he once dismissed prop trading, why his view changed, and what he now thinks the model means for brokers, clients and risk managers. We explore subscription-fee dependency, the high reneging rate, and the long-term challenge: how brokers can build a more stable and honest version of the model. Drew also talks about the traffic advantage standalone prop firms have built and why brokers may still win in the long run if they take the right approach.

  • Executive Interview | Remonda Z. Kirketerp Møller| CEO & Founder Muinmos | FMLS:25

    Executive Interview | Remonda Z. Kirketerp Møller| CEO & Founder Muinmos | FMLS:25

    In this interview, Remonda Z. Kirketerp Møller, founder of Muinmos, breaks down the state of AI in regtech and what responsible adoption really looks like for brokers. We talk about rising fragmentation, the pressures around compliance accuracy, and why most firms are still in the early stages of AI maturity. Ramanda also shares insights on regulator sandboxes, shifting expectations around accountability, and the current reality of MiCA licensing and passporting in Europe. A concise look at where compliance, onboarding, and AI-driven processes are heading next.

    In this interview, Remonda Z. Kirketerp Møller, founder of Muinmos, breaks down the state of AI in regtech and what responsible adoption really looks like for brokers. We talk about rising fragmentation, the pressures around compliance accuracy, and why most firms are still in the early stages of AI maturity. Ramanda also shares insights on regulator sandboxes, shifting expectations around accountability, and the current reality of MiCA licensing and passporting in Europe. A concise look at where compliance, onboarding, and AI-driven processes are heading next.

  • Executive Interview | Aydin Bonabi | Founder, Surveill | FMLS:25

    Executive Interview | Aydin Bonabi | Founder, Surveill | FMLS:25

    In this conversation, we speak with Aydin Bonabi, CEO and co-founder of Surveill, a firm focused on fraud detection and AI-driven compliance tools for financial institutions. We start with Aydin’s view of the Summit and the challenges brokers face as fraud tactics grow more complex. He explains how firms can stay ahead through real-time signals, data patterns, and early-stage detection. We also talk about AI training and why compliance teams often struggle to keep models accurate, fair, and aligned with regulatory expectations. Aydin breaks down what “good” AI training looks like inside a financial environment, including the importance of clean data, domain expertise, and human oversight. He closes with a clear message: fraud is scaling, and so must the tools that stop it.

    In this conversation, we speak with Aydin Bonabi, CEO and co-founder of Surveill, a firm focused on fraud detection and AI-driven compliance tools for financial institutions. We start with Aydin’s view of the Summit and the challenges brokers face as fraud tactics grow more complex. He explains how firms can stay ahead through real-time signals, data patterns, and early-stage detection. We also talk about AI training and why compliance teams often struggle to keep models accurate, fair, and aligned with regulatory expectations. Aydin breaks down what “good” AI training looks like inside a financial environment, including the importance of clean data, domain expertise, and human oversight. He closes with a clear message: fraud is scaling, and so must the tools that stop it.

  • Exness expands its presence in Africa: Inside our interview with Paul Margarites in Cape Town

    Exness expands its presence in Africa: Inside our interview with Paul Margarites in Cape Town

    Finance Magnates met with Paul Margarites, Exness regional commercial director for Sub-Saharan Africa, during a visit to the firm’s office opening in Cape Town. In this talk, led by Andrea Badiola Mateos, Co-CEO at Finance Magnates, Paul shares views on the South African trading space, local user behavior, mobile trends, regulation, team growth, and how Exness plans to grow in more markets across the region. @Exness Read the article at: https://www.financemagnates.com/thought-leadership/exness-expands-its-presence-in-africa-inside-our-interview-with-paul-margarites/ #exness #financemagnates #exnesstrading #CFDtrading #tradeonline #africanews #capetown

    Finance Magnates met with Paul Margarites, Exness regional commercial director for Sub-Saharan Africa, during a visit to the firm’s office opening in Cape Town. In this talk, led by Andrea Badiola Mateos, Co-CEO at Finance Magnates, Paul shares views on the South African trading space, local user behavior, mobile trends, regulation, team growth, and how Exness plans to grow in more markets across the region. @Exness Read the article at: https://www.financemagnates.com/thought-leadership/exness-expands-its-presence-in-africa-inside-our-interview-with-paul-margarites/ #exness #financemagnates #exnesstrading #CFDtrading #tradeonline #africanews #capetown