Should Forex & CFD Affiliates Be Regulated?

by Felipe Erazo
  • Finance Magnates interviewed some experts to talk about the regulatory matter.
  • Analysts mostly agreed on regulating the landscape.
forex

The regulation of the Forex space around the world has been getting stronger over time. This is because the regulatory entities have reinforced their rules in order to combat crimes, such as money laundering or the financing of terrorism.

However, the topic of affiliates and introducing brokers (IBs) has always remained a grey area where the laws do not fully govern it, at least in the vast majority of jurisdictions globally.

The market for Forex and CFD affiliates is a very large one and moves millions of dollars for brokers worldwide. The importance given to this niche is so great that many brokers have focused their marketing strategies on strengthening this front within their line of business, prioritizing them above others.

In this analysis, we talked to two experts in the field who will give us their thoughts on the question: should Forex and CFD affiliates be regulated?

Regulatory Scheme in Specific Regions

Giancarlo Lionti, the Global Head of Affiliate Marketing at Skilling, believes that the environment should be regulated and provided the following reasons: “Considering the increasing number of requirements coming from the Financial Regulators and the limited control that a CFD Broker can have on its affiliates’ businesses, I would personally support the regulation of the Affiliate Business in Forex & CFD trading. It’s not rare that publishers and marketers don’t follow the indications provided by the regulated brokers they work with and, in my opinion, it is not fair that a Broker can get in regulatory and financial trouble for something that is not 100% under its control.”

He added that this would reduce the internal cost of time and resources required to run a compliant affiliate business and ‘protect both brokers and users from fraudulent affiliate activities’.

In the same line, Eduardo Delgado, the Director at Fintexify, shares the vision of agreeing that affiliates should be regulated, specifically in regions like the US and the European Union. “I think that a clear regulation for introducing brokers and affiliates makes their business more transparent and sustainable over time. Nowadays, unregulated introducing brokers and money managers face big challenges to carry out their activities. They are forced to go work with offshore entities which entails different forms of risks for them and their clients,” he said.

An 'Affiliate License'?

Additionally, Lionti talked about the introduction of a hypothetic license for affiliates: “On the other hand, the introduction of an ‘Affiliate License’ would reduce the number of potential partners available on the market, who would then increase their Cost per Acquisition (CPA) expectations, decreasing the profitability of the Affiliate Business in the industry.”

Delgado shared his experience in terms of regulation in the EU: “Based on my experience, in some EU countries, most IBs and MMs do not clearly understand the process to be compliant with their respective country’s regulations. Oftentimes the legal government officials themselves do not provide clear guidance. Precise and comprehensive guidance from regulatory authorities would help.”

EDITOR'S NOTE: This analysis is part of a series of Finance Magnates articles dissecting the latest trends in the online retail forex industries around the world. You can also read about developments in the retail forex scenes in Africa, the United Kingdom, North America, Australia, and Latin America by following the links.

The regulation of the Forex space around the world has been getting stronger over time. This is because the regulatory entities have reinforced their rules in order to combat crimes, such as money laundering or the financing of terrorism.

However, the topic of affiliates and introducing brokers (IBs) has always remained a grey area where the laws do not fully govern it, at least in the vast majority of jurisdictions globally.

The market for Forex and CFD affiliates is a very large one and moves millions of dollars for brokers worldwide. The importance given to this niche is so great that many brokers have focused their marketing strategies on strengthening this front within their line of business, prioritizing them above others.

In this analysis, we talked to two experts in the field who will give us their thoughts on the question: should Forex and CFD affiliates be regulated?

Regulatory Scheme in Specific Regions

Giancarlo Lionti, the Global Head of Affiliate Marketing at Skilling, believes that the environment should be regulated and provided the following reasons: “Considering the increasing number of requirements coming from the Financial Regulators and the limited control that a CFD Broker can have on its affiliates’ businesses, I would personally support the regulation of the Affiliate Business in Forex & CFD trading. It’s not rare that publishers and marketers don’t follow the indications provided by the regulated brokers they work with and, in my opinion, it is not fair that a Broker can get in regulatory and financial trouble for something that is not 100% under its control.”

He added that this would reduce the internal cost of time and resources required to run a compliant affiliate business and ‘protect both brokers and users from fraudulent affiliate activities’.

In the same line, Eduardo Delgado, the Director at Fintexify, shares the vision of agreeing that affiliates should be regulated, specifically in regions like the US and the European Union. “I think that a clear regulation for introducing brokers and affiliates makes their business more transparent and sustainable over time. Nowadays, unregulated introducing brokers and money managers face big challenges to carry out their activities. They are forced to go work with offshore entities which entails different forms of risks for them and their clients,” he said.

An 'Affiliate License'?

Additionally, Lionti talked about the introduction of a hypothetic license for affiliates: “On the other hand, the introduction of an ‘Affiliate License’ would reduce the number of potential partners available on the market, who would then increase their Cost per Acquisition (CPA) expectations, decreasing the profitability of the Affiliate Business in the industry.”

Delgado shared his experience in terms of regulation in the EU: “Based on my experience, in some EU countries, most IBs and MMs do not clearly understand the process to be compliant with their respective country’s regulations. Oftentimes the legal government officials themselves do not provide clear guidance. Precise and comprehensive guidance from regulatory authorities would help.”

EDITOR'S NOTE: This analysis is part of a series of Finance Magnates articles dissecting the latest trends in the online retail forex industries around the world. You can also read about developments in the retail forex scenes in Africa, the United Kingdom, North America, Australia, and Latin America by following the links.

About the Author: Felipe Erazo
Felipe Erazo
  • 1036 Articles
  • 41 Followers
About the Author: Felipe Erazo
Felipe earned a degree in journalism at the University of Chile with the highest honour in the overall ranking, and he also holds a Bachelor of Arts in Social Communication. In addition, he has been working as a freelance writer and Forex/crypto analyst, with experience gained from several forex broker firms and crypto-related media outlets around the world. He has been involved in the world of online forex trading since 2010 and in the crypto sphere since 2015.
  • 1036 Articles
  • 41 Followers

More from the Author

Retail FX

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|} !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}